New York, New York

Enter quantity and add to cart:

Heat Sensitive - sensitive to high temperature or summer perishable


Featuring sites and flavors from all around the city, this towering trio of nostalgic city postcard keepsake picture boxes are packed with the inimitable flavors of New York.

This collection contains a pound of fresh baked New York Rugelach; I Heart NY round chocolate tin; a dozen traditional black and white cookies, just like the ones featured in the famous Seinfeld episode; NY Mints; NY Taxi Treats; 3 large Fat Witch brownies from our very own Chelsea Market; Raisin Crisps from Eli Zabar's; Tate's Chocolate Chip Cookies; NYC Checker Cab Crunch; New York Style bagel crisps; locally handmade Fatty Sundays toffee bites; a souvenir NYC lollipop; a box of chewy Salt of the Earth cookies; and our very own CMB chocolate tiles.

This bountiful present can be sent to celebrate a special occasion, greet someone during the holiday season, cheer up a homesick New Yorker, or to welcome someone new to the greatest city on earth.

Gift Contents

New York Rugelach (1/2lb)
New York Taxi Treats (2oz)
Salt of the Earth Cookies (8oz)
Black & White Cookies (8oz)
New York Checker Cab Crunch (6oz)
New York Mints (0.56oz)
New York Style Bagel Chips (6oz)
Eli's Raisin Crisp (7oz)
Tate's Chocolate Chip Cookies (7oz)
Fatty Sundays Chocolate Covered Pretzels
I Heart NY Chocolate Tin (2.2oz)
Fat Witch Brownies (4 x 3.5oz)
Chelsea Market Baskets Chocolate Squares (10 piece pack)
New York Boxes - Set of 3
*Please note that we reserve the right to substitute a product of equal or greater value.


  • This item is sensitive to heat and if it's shipping to a warm destination that is more than 2 travel days away, we suggest using an expedited ship method.

Producers Represented:

Fat Witch Bakery
Tate's Bake Shop


Fast but questionable content
Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Dec 29, 2015
I specifically chose this item because it is supposed to include black & white cookies. The recipient informed it that it did not. I apologized but did not press to find out other omissions or substitutions that might have occurred. Next time I'll look for a more reliable gift.

New York, New York
Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Apr 15, 2016
Great efficient service.
carol Edmead

Loved the selection in your gift basket
Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Review star icon Jan 12, 2019
The items were great and the selection was tastefully displayed. My recipient loved it!
June Finlay

You May Also Like